12 February 2010

Ayn Rand in India?

Listening to an interview with Jennifer Burns, assistant professor of history at the University of Virginia and author of Goddess of the Market: Ayn Rand and the American Right, I was surprised to hear her assert that Ayn Rand's novels have developed a large readership in, of all places, India.  I quickly contacted my students from last year's classes I taught at the National Law University in Jodhpur to see if this were so and, indeed, it is.

A link to the November/December 2009 issue Foreign Policy http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/10/19/howard_roark_in_new_delhi
presents Professor Burns's explanation in terms of a deliberate turning away form the strongly communitarian ethos that undergirds Indian society.

The mixed attitudes toward capitalism I found in India lead me to doubt that a "Randian" justification--based on an unadulterated self-regard--will ever captivate the minds and hearts of Indians.  This seems especially so when one considers Rand's ethics of rationalistic moral objectivism in light of the lesser regard that Indian philosophy generally grants pure reason.  Nonetheless, India's accession to a modern market society from a traditional order centered around the joint family requires some sort justification.  Perhaps a future entry or two (or more) from a Christian perspective will prove helpful.

4 comments:

  1. And what a splendid testament this Indian phenomenon is to tabula rasa volitional mankind.

    You may or may not be equally surprised at the growing numbers of Christians who are so desperate for Rand's precise definitions, principles, and general explanations of the proper human society — radical laissez-faire capitalism — who are publicly heralding her prophetic literature and embracing her ideas fully aware of her atheism.

    It confounds her would be detractors no end, but I have for a while now seen an emerging rationalization on their part that ranges from deism to Thomism. In each case their mystical faith is stashed in the cupboard of God while they pursue knowledge, liberty, and happiness on earth per the reason of Ayn Rand.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A prophet is without honor in his own country! I wish we could lay claim to Vishal Mangalwadi or Sundar Krishnan instead of Ayn Rand.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Exhibit A: A sample of the quest to embrace Objectivism without letting go of Christianity.

    http://phlsphr.wordpress.com/2010/02/14/christian-objectivism/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Exhibit B: A sample of a quest to embrace Objectivism without letting go of Buddhism.

    http://www.muditajournal.com/archives/617.php

    ReplyDelete